Innovation Geography

Met Mehran Gul and got a signed copy of his Bracken Bower Prize winning book “The New Geography of Innovation”. That man has an incredible memory – when I told him my name he said – I know that name – are we on LinkedIn and yes we were connected. While countries competitively try to outdo each other in the innovation arena – he has some sound advice:
1. The innovation competition is narrowing – it is not about who owns the resources but how you leverage geography
2. Valuation is simply a number of what the market perception is of the stock and the amount of money investors want to put into it. All eyes on @Anthropic. However, a stock valued less in China or UK does not make it any less valuable (look at the price Deep Minds was bought). It does say a lot about countries and its ability to value its own home-grown enterprises. Today both Chinese and American firms are grocery shopping for discounted firms across the globe.
3. Countries and their firms need to choose their strategy carefully considering
· Geopolitics: He spoke about how Singapore was the second largest market for NVIDIA chips invoicing (1/5 of NVIDIA earnings though less than 1% was routed through the country).
· Opportunity: Naspers valuation, one of the largest African companies, rose on the opportune investment of $32 million for 46.5% of Tencent stock in 2001. This investment strategy in technology firms is being pursued by Sovereign Wealth Firms of the Gulf and Norway. Hence Vietnam’s rise with friendshoring between the two top AI patented countries.
· Talent: Mehran made a distinction between attracting talent and the ability to retain it. Talent migrates to opportunity – discounted education, quality of life for families, or manage a business (access to resources including R&D). I think the R&D mindset needs to be coupled with opportunities and the question is (1) do you have access to a market (AI firms need 50 million customers and others need manufacturing value chains) (2) for R&D itself – what kind of ecosystem do you have – it is not collaborative and self-sustaining – it is dead on the water. Here is where defense funding has helped flourish basic research (which is dying today from lack of funding, the killing off of creative studies and social sciences and stolen IP – from AI companies).
· Resources: Firms will always find resources – so what can you offer? . Singapore is an exemplar country in terms of reinventing itself with so few resources – by becoming the gateway to Asia, changing regulations, and the state acting as a VC for tech funds. Its about investing in disruptive tech before it reaches commercialization: Germany’s SPRIND invested in BioNTech (like DARPA did in Moderna’s mRNA).
· Mindset for Innovation: Lifestyle is not enough for innovation – it is a mindset. Mehran pushed against the fact that defense resources helped Silicon Valley flourish. His argument was that Boston had access to those resources a lot earlier. Silicon Valley has a futures orientation with talent, resources and this entrepreneurial culture – no barriers to talent movement, no stigma to failure, - most countries do not have this. They aspire but have so many subtle roadblocks that make it impossible to truly flourish.
Mehran had 110 slides! But read his well-researched book. So much to learn!!



Comments